CPP Says NEC Dual Nationals Ban Not Aimed at Pung Chhiv Kek

Why Bin Chhin has fought against the dual citizenship Cambodians? Cambodian constitution allows Cambodian people the freedom to hold multinationalities. Many elites, dignitaries and politicians from both parties are holding at least two nationalities. King Norodom Sihamuni is possibly holding multi-nationalities: Cambodian by birth, Czechoslovakian and France by naturalization. Dr. Pung Chiv Kek is known for her Cambodian by birth, Canadian and France by naturalization. Many politicians and ministers from CPP are holding multi-nationalities as well. Many politicians and ministers from CNRP are holding multi-nationalities as well. Many Cambodian millionaires, investors and citizens are holding multi-nationalities. Cambodians who are living overseas are launching campaign called The CEROC to acquire for the Rights for Voting in Cambodia elections because those have never given up their Cambodian citizenship. Their love and spirit for Cambodia is to help develop in all fields of this country. There are also many foreign-born citizens who have become Cambodian citizens. Those are likely many Vietnamese citizens who have been naturalized into Cambodians (sic). Alex Gonsales has dedicated his nearly 10 years in Cambodia to help protect the Araeng natural site. Angelina Jolie is known for her Cambodian citizenship as in special case. How about Dr. Beat Richner who has dedicated his money and life for the children health of Cambodia? The people who are holding multi-nationalities have helped develop Cambodia gigantically. The National Election Committee must be participated by all streams of Cambodian citizenship. Bin Chhin and the CPP must adopt broader policy for the benefit of Cambodia. The reasons explained by Bin Chhin not to allow dual citizens to hold position in NEC are not yet rational, and it has shown only dwarf policy and cheap mentality, or it has shown only “threatening or intimidating approach” is not working well with dual citizens, but it has worked well with single citizens.

CPP Says NEC Dual Nationals Ban Not Aimed at Pung Chhiv Kek
BY | NOVEMBER 18, 2014


Deputy Prime Minister Bin Chhin said Monday that the ruling CPP’s demand that dual nationals be banned from sitting on a reformed election commission is not intended to prevent Licadho President Pung Chhiv Kek from becoming the “neutral” ninth member of the new institution.

CNRP President Sam Rainsy and Prime Minister Hun Sen signed a deal on July 22 that led the opposition party’s 55 lawmakers to end their boycott of parliament in exchange for an overhaul of the CPP-led National Election Committee (NEC).

Jamie Meach, the wife of imprisoned CNRP official Meach Sovannara, speaks to reporters outside Phnom Penh's Prey Sar prison on Monday. (Siv Channa/The Cambodia Daily)

Under the deal, each party will have the right to select four members of the NEC, with the ninth tie-breaking member chosen by both. Ms. Chhiv Kek was approved for the ninth position on July 28 and the CNRP took its seats the next week.

The subsequent talks to draft the law for the new institution have been deadlocked since early October, with the CPP now demanding that NEC members not hold foreign passports. Ms. Chhiv Kek is also a French and Canadian citizen.

“It is not targeted at any individual person,” Mr. Chhin, the CPP’s lead delegate in election reform talk, said of his party’s demands after a weekly meeting Monday. “This draft law, we draft in general. We do not draft it to target on this or that persons. So please make it clear, it’s not about that.”

Mr. Chhin insisted that the ruling party still supports Ms. Chhiv Kek’s candidacy for the ninth slot on a new NEC.

“We support [her] but we don’t know she has two nationalities or whatever. Don’t make assumptions about that. It’s the wrong evaluation, we have written [the draft], without targeting this or that person. Don’t be confused,” Mr. Chhin said.

“We want single-nationals because they can prove they have Khmer citizenship and they can work without links to other areas,” he explained. “We want them to be neutral since we do not want to hear of there being any [outside] influence.”

He added that Ms. Chhiv Kek would always have the option of renouncing her foreign passports if necessary.

“We are just assuming that she will be like this or that. Sometimes, they can give it up, we don’t know,” he said.

CNRP official Kuoy Bunroeun, who has led the opposition party in the election reform talks, said that his party would not back down over its rejection of the CPP’s demands.

“We want it to be more open,” Mr. Bunroeun said after Monday’s meeting. “We know that some people, because of circumstances, are forced to have [foreign passports]. Secondly, we want those living abroad and holding other nationalities—and having the experiences and knowledge—to serve here.”

According to the July 22 deal, if the two parties are unable to come to an agreement to establish the reformed NEC, the current CPP-led NEC will continue to organize elections.

On Friday, Ms. Chhiv Kek declined to comment when asked if she would consider renouncing her foreign passports if it was required for her to join the NEC.

“[I]t is still too early to comment at this time,” Ms. Chhiv Kek said in an email.

Last week, prominent opposition official Meach Sovannara was arrested the morning after the last round of failed election reform talks, with the Phnom Penh Municipal Court imprisoning him on four-month-old charges of “insurrection.”

CNRP leaders have claimed that his imprisonment is a ploy to push them to fold to the CPP’s demands, but the opposition official’s wife said Monday that the party should not back down.

“If the imprisonment of my family is an exchange for the independence of the NEC, then I agree to have my family imprisoned,” Jamie Meach, who lives in the U.S., told a crowd of media after visiting Mr. Sovannara in Prey Sar prison. “I sacrifice everything.”

By telephone, Ms. Meach said that her jailed husband, who is also a U.S. citizen, had told her not to let the CNRP make concessions in the NEC negotiations to secure his release.

“He told me that he would not allow anyone to use him as a political hostage in exchange for something that could ruin the new NEC or for any other political issue,” Ms. Meach said.

U.S. Embassy spokesman Jay Raman said embassy officials visited Mr. Sovannara in prison last week and are providing him with the regular assistance given to U.S citizens.

In front of the prison Monday, CNRP Vice President Kem Sokha said that he had also met with Mr. Sovannara and would heed his demands for the opposition not to fold.

“His message was that he continues demanding for justice for the nation, and he suggests to [the] party not to take the matter of his arrest to be bartered to take the negotiations backward,” the opposition leader said. “I told him that the CNRP’s position is that his arrest cannot be bartered in the talks.”

“I already advised to the [CNRP] negotiating group scheduled to meet at 3 o’clock that our negotiating stance is that we will not soften in exchange for anything,” Mr. Sokha added.

Yet he said that the opposition party would continue negotiating separately for the official’s immediate release.

“But we want a resolution as we have had in the past,” he said. “I hope Meach Sovannara will be released soon.”

(Additional reporting by Alex Willemyns)